‘Diversifying’ Social Investment: European welfare states and immigrant integration in the wake of the COVID-19 crisis

Highlights

COVID-19 exposed deep welfare gaps for migrants in Europe. Diversifying social investment with tailored, needs-based support can advance integration outcomes and social cohesion.

  • COVID-19 exposed deep inequalities between migrant and native-born populations in European welfare states, with immigrants facing higher unemployment, greater poverty risk, and reduced access to social protection. 
  • Traditional social investment approaches have largely excluded migrants or treated them as a uniform group, missing the diversity of legal statuses, socioeconomic backgrounds, and integration needs. 
  • Diversifying social investment to include tailored, needs-based support for migrants—such as language training, employment services, and health care—can yield economic returns and strengthen social cohesion. 

Across Europe, the COVID-19 pandemic has strengthened awareness of the importance of robust, well-functioning welfare states in helping individuals, families, and communities weather threats to their lives and livelihoods. Initial EU and Member State responses to the pandemic and its economic fallout were much more vigorous than responses to other recent economic shocks, such as the Great Recession and the European debt crisis. Even so, European societies will likely have to contend with long-term social and economic impacts, which in many cases are exacerbating existing inequalities.

The shift in the structure and goals of welfare spending since the start of the pandemic can be understood through the prism of “social investment.” In recent decades, European welfare states have moved away from a predominantly reactive focus on financial safety nets that protect individuals during periods of unemployment and illness, and toward investing in people’s human capital and employability to help them navigate life transitions and drive growth in advanced knowledge economies. Looking ahead, the success of social-investment policies will depend on their ability to account for immigration and diversity, increasingly prominent features of European societies that are central to understanding the nature and development of socioeconomic inequalities.

This report explores whether the social-investment approach to welfare states could serve as a tool for post-pandemic recovery—particularly in diverse, immigrant-receiving societies. It examines how European welfare systems fared and adapted during the Great Recession, how social investment seeks to balance social and economic goals, and how lessons from recent immigrant integration policy developments could help improve the reach, accessibility, and relevance of social-investment initiatives.

Table of Contents

1  Introduction

2  Is More Welfare the Answer to Crisis? Insights from the Great Recession for Future Welfare Reform

3  The Social-Investment Approach: Balancing Social and Economic Goals in Times of Uncertainty
Social Investment and the Post-Pandemic Recovery

4  Social Investment and Immigration
A. Migration and Diversity: The Weak Spot of Social Investment?
B. Integration Policy: A Laboratory for Social Investment?

5  Conclusion: Social Investment and the Future of Diverse Societies

Integration Futures Working Group

The Integration Futures Working Group convenes senior European policymakers and others to debate forward-looking integration policy through peer exchange, original research, and off-the-record dialogue to achieve better integration outcomes.