As Smuggling Networks Professionalize and Become More Transnational, Governments Should Target the Broader Ecosystem
- Media contact
-
Michelle Mittelstadt
202 266 1910 [email protected]
WASHINGTON, DC — As countries in North America, Europe and beyond seek to crack down on irregular and other spontaneous migration, smuggling networks have grown more professional, transnational and reliant on digital tools that extend their reach and lessen their risk. Measures aimed at migrants or low-level operators, which can reduce arrivals in the short term, have done little to disrupt smuggling networks—and in the case of hardened borders, have even driven up demand for smuggling services.
As a result, government responses must adapt and use more sophisticated tools that target the networks themselves, a new report from the Migration Policy Institute’s Transatlantic Council on Migration contends.
Falling numbers of irregular arrivals, seen since 2025 across much of North America and Europe, do not necessarily signal a lasting decline in human smuggling or the dismantling of smuggling networks, writes Matt Herbert of the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime. In A Moving Target: The Evolution of Human Smuggling, Herbertnotes that these highly resilient and profitable networks can respond nimbly to policy changes, redirecting activity to less-used routes and markets, and leaving governments vulnerable to a rapid resurgence in arrivals.
The report sketches how smuggling operations increasingly are relying on specialized subcontractors, legal businesses, corrupt officials and organized criminal groups. Digital tools help smugglers recruit clients, coordinate travel and move payments, while air travel and other legal transport can be combined with unauthorized journeys.
"Although changes in the smuggling industry have contributed to its growth, ineffective or outdated responses by state actors share the blame," Herbert writes.
Government responses have often focused on border enforcement and arrests of exposed, low-level operators but have often done little to disrupt the broader infrastructure or reach network leaders, financial facilitators, private-sector enablers and complicit state agents.
The report recommends that governments:
- Expand beyond the current criminal-network-based approach and map the full contemporary smuggling ecosystem, including its financial facilitators, subcontractors, businesses and corrupt officials, to identify the actors whose disruption could have the greatest impact.
- Turn to underutilized tools such as financial sanctions and visa bans alongside investigations and prosecutions.
- Involve relevant private-sector partners, including airlines, while carefully assessing the risks of working with non-state armed groups in states along key smuggling routes.
- Build flexible, routes-based partnerships among origin, transit and destination countries, backed by clear goals, measures of success and operational plans. Stronger coordination across governments should include law enforcement, diplomatic, finance and commerce agencies.
“Policymakers should recognize that professionalization of smuggling, broader smuggling ecosystems, hybrid migration and greater use of technology are not passing phenomena but rather likely to continue and deepen in the coming years. Geopolitical instability, political challenges in transit states and constraints on state capacity are also likely to persist for the foreseeable future,” the report notes. “This underscores the need for new approaches to assessing and acting against smuggling groups.”
Read the report here: www.migrationpolicy.org/publication/evolution-human-smuggling.
For more work from the Transatlantic Council on Migration, visit: www.migrationpolicy.org/initiative/transatlantic-council-migration.