As New York State’s Health-Care System Comes under Mounting Pressure, Underemployed Immigrant Professionals Represent an Underutilized Talent Pool
- Media contact
-
Michelle Mittelstadt
202 266 1910 [email protected]
WASHINGTON, DC — The state of New York is projected to have only about three family medicine doctors for every five it needs by 2038 and already faces a shortage of more than 5,000 registered nurses. And an estimated 8 million New Yorkers live in a federally designated health professional shortage area. At the same time, at least 24,000 immigrants with medical or health sciences degrees are working in New York in low-skilled jobs, are unemployed or are out of the labor force, according to a new Migration Policy Institute (MPI) analysis of 2024 Census Bureau data.
These underemployed immigrant health-care professionals, who are already living in New York, represent an underutilized pool of talent that could be more fully deployed as aging hits the overall population and the health-care workforce itself, analysts Jeanne Batalova, Michael Fix and Kate Hooper write in a report published today.
The state already depends heavily on foreign-born professionals. Immigrants make up 23 percent of New York's population but are 37 percent of its physicians and 29 percent of its nurses—among the highest shares in the United States. Nearly one in five international medical graduates completing a U.S. residency does so in New York. At the same time, federal immigration policy changes to J-1 and H-1B visas, travel bans and longer visa processing times are narrowing the pipeline of new arrivals.
About 71 percent of New York’s underemployed immigrant health-care professionals have at least 10 years of U.S. residence, with more than half earning their degree in the United States, MPI’s analysis finds. Seventy-six percent are women.
While barriers to the recognition of internationally earned credentials represent one reason why these professionals are underemployed, there are others as well: limited English instruction for professionals, employer preference for U.S. work experience and inflexible funding for training programs. New York stakeholders interviewed for this study reported that some underemployed immigrant professionals, including lawfully present ones, hesitated to enroll in public training programs for fear of immigration enforcement.
Legal status is a factor, but not the main one. Drawing on MPI’s unique methodology to assign legal status in Census Bureau data, the report finds that 87 percent of the underemployed health-care professionals in New York as of 2023 were naturalized citizens, green-card holders or temporary visa holders. Just 13 percent were unauthorized immigrants.
Among all underemployed immigrants in New York with a medical or health-related degree, 68 percent were fully English proficient, with many speaking languages common among the state's limited English proficient patients, such as Spanish, Chinese, Bengali, Russian, Haitian Creole and Arabic.
Pointing to models in other states to tackle credential recognition and other hurdles for the nation’s 1.3 million underemployed health-care professionals, of whom 310,000 are immigrants, the authors recommend that New York policymakers consider:
- Funding English instruction tailored to health-care professionals on a broader scale
- Creating a path from temporary to full licensure for internationally trained physicians
- Accepting credential evaluations from multiple providers for internationally trained nurses
- Providing stipends or grants during exam preparation and re-entry
- Tracking licensure outcomes by licensing pathway to advance evidence-based reforms.
Immigrants are not the only health professionals who are underemployed. About 52,000 U.S.-born New Yorkers with health or medical degrees are also underemployed, and many of the reforms proposed would help them too.
“At a time of deepening workforce shortages and tighter federal immigration restrictions, such reforms could help New York make better use of talent already in the state while expanding access to care in rural and other underserved communities,” the report concludes.
The report, Making New Yorkers Healthier: Immigrant Health Professionals’ Untapped Potential, is available here: www.migrationpolicy.org/publication/new-york-immigrant-health-professionals.